Not all vanilla is the same


Not all vanilla is the same
Vanilla is a delicious flavour found in a great many dessert recipes: creams (crème pâtissière and custard, for example), ice creams, but also cakes and entremets.
Whenever you need to add this vanilla note, you have several possible choices because vanilla is commercially available in different forms, and at different prices...
14 K 5/5 (14 reviews)
Rate this page:
Last modified on: December 14th 2017
For this postComments Latest posts Follow
For this post: Comment Follow Ask me a question Send to a friend
We could try to make a mini-inventory of the possibilities, and of the associated quality, but to make it simple, there are 2 forms of vanilla: the pods, and the rest.

And the vanilla bean is the best: you are sure of what you are handling, it is impossible to make fake vanilla beans (well... for the moment). A vanilla bean is the fruit of the vanilla tree that has been dried and prepared. It doesn't smell much like vanilla, because its secret is inside, the tiny black seeds, rather pasty, which are what makes vanilla so valuable. To use a pod, you split it in 2 lengthwise and scrape out, with the back of a knife, the small black grains it contains and add them to your preparation.

Grains from a vanilla pod



It's the presence of those little black seeds that are your assurance that you're dealing with something that actually contains real vanilla.

Vanilla Bean seeds in a custard



There are different varieties of vanilla beans, depending on their origin, Indian Ocean, Tahiti, South America, ... they are more or less expensive, and more or less strong in flavour. Personally, I have a weakness for the vanilla known as "Bourbon" from the island of Reunion. If you have to buy some, know that it is not cheap, but that it is normal (quality you know...), and that you should choose pods that are quite supple and slightly oily to the touch, it is a sign of freshness, because they dry with time.

Only after that comes anything made from pods: powder, paste, extract, purée, etc. For all these, no secret, you have to read the label very carefully so as not to find yourself, as I did, with a "liquid vanilla extract" which in fact contains 99% water and sugar syrup and 1% vanilla.
And finally, at the very bottom of the scale, the very cheap vanillin, which is not vanilla, but a pure synthetic product that just gives a standardised vanilla taste. As the late French food critic Jean-Pierre Coffe used to say, "C'est de la merde..." (it's rubbish).

The picture would not be complete without mentioning vanilla sugar, these small sachets are widely used, many recipes no longer indicate a weight, but just "add 1 sachet of vanilla sugar", and it should be understood "10 grams".
It is rather a good product (be careful to read the label anyway, there is not always only sugar and vanilla in it, and especially beware of very cheap packets, and right next to it, of "vanillin sugar"), but that you can very advantageously prepare yourself at home.

Vanilla sugar



By the way, run away from all the pseudo recipes that tell you that sticking a vanilla bean in a jar of sugar will give you vanilla sugar, it's a big lie because the bean is quite airtight.

As you can see, there is vanilla and there is vanilla, and you always have to be careful about what you use, as soon as you do a little baking.

Note that whenever possible, you should give the taste of the vanilla beans time to express itself, i.e. don't cook immediately, but let it rest. If you are making an ice cream, a flan, or a vanilla cream for example, it will be better with a more pronounced taste, if you make your preparation the day before, and let it rest overnight in the fridge in a closed container.

To sum up: Whenever you need to put vanilla in a recipe, prefer a whole pod, and let it rest if possible. If you want vanilla sugar, feel free to make it yourself, it'll be very good, much cheaper, and you'll be able to say "I made it!" (which is, of course, priceless).
Latest posts
Added cocoa powder: why it makes your cakes dry
Are you making a recipe—a cake, for example—and want to turn it into a chocolate version? Adding a few spoonfuls of cocoa powder seems like the simplest solution. However, the result is often disappointing: you end up with a cake that’s drier, denser, and goes stale quickly. This is due to...
November 10th 20261,1805
Sprinkle salt from the right height
When you need to salt something—for example, fish fillets before cooking them—you’ll naturally sprinkle them with a pinch of salt using your fingers. There’s nothing particularly remarkable about this very ordinary gesture, which is done all the time in the kitchen, and yet there’s a...
October 14th 20262,0355
How to Properly Fill a Jar
When you have a jar in your kitchen that’s almost empty—flour or almond flour, for example—you’ll probably refill it before it’s completely empty. And that’s a great way to go about it—no one wants to run out of an ingredient right in the middle of a recipe. Once you’ve...
October 2nd 20261,3965
Serving Temperature for Wine
When it comes to serving wine, you may (like me) have a fairly simple rule of thumb: red wine at room temperature, and white, rosé, and yellow wines in the fridge until it’s time to serve them. It’s very easy to remember, but it’s a bit simplistic, and you’ll see that there’s a much...
September 23th 20261,4165
Hot Emulsified Sauces
In French cuisine, sauces are a very important part of a recipe—not just a side dish. In fact, they’re so important that, especially since the time of Auguste Escoffier, they’ve been classified into categories. And among these categories are “hot emulsified sauces,” or lukewarm ones. ...
September 9th 20261,8555
Other articles you might also like
Can I trust my oven?
Can you really trust your oven? This is an important question as we are always tempted to take the temperature indicated as gospel truth and, unfortunately, this is rarely very precise. .
July 4th 201135 K4.6
The window-pane test in bread-making
Home bread-makers often ask themselves "Have I kneaded my dough long enough?" A good question, as dough that is insufficiently kneaded will not rise properly or will fall flat when the top is slashed, which is very frustrating. To know when the dough is ready, one can rely on the length of...
June 16th 2021100 K 23.9
Too much sweet and savoury
There is a food trend which is creeping in everywhere in France right now: mixing sweet with savoury. In some restaurants, it is becoming difficult to order a classic dish, like “roast veal” for instance, without being served fruits in the garnish or honey/conserves/syrup in the sauce or cooked...
November 3rd 201129 K4.5
Fruits which can ruin your jelly
There are many ways of making a fruit mousse, but one of the simplest is to prepare a fruit jelly (basically a fresh fruit coulis with gelatine) and then mix this jelly before it sets completely with whipped cream. The result is perfect for filling a charlotte, for example. But do beware;...
March 6th 201382 K4.0
The 3 kinds of meringue
Meringue – what could be simpler? Just beaten egg whites with sugar added. This makes a fairly stiff mixture which can then be cooked in a cool oven to create those lovely, light confections. But in the world of professional patisserie, meringue comes in three different kinds. Even if the...
June 14th 201368 K4.5
Post a comment or question
Posted by
I am not a leaving thing
Follow this page

Receive an e-mail as soon as this page is modified or receives a new comment.

I am not a leaving thing
We'll never share your e-mail address with anyone else.
Alternatively: you can subscribe to the mailing list of cooking-ez.com. You'll receive an email for each new recipe published on the site.

Back to top of page