Key Lime Pie for Jeremy


Key Lime Pie for Jeremy
Key Lime Pie is a famous speciality from the Keys region of southern Florida.

This delicious tart is usually made with Key limes - a special variety. But in this simplified version, normal limes will work perfectly well.
109 K 3.9/5 (20 reviews)437486
Grade this recipe:
Keywords:
Last modified on: September 30th 2012
For this recipe: Printable Follow
For 1 pie, you will need:

Change these quantities to make:
Change measures:
Times for this recipe
Preparation
1 hour 35 min.
Resting
2 hours
Cooking
15 min.
All in all
3 hours 50 min.
Preparation 1 hour 35 min.
Resting 2 hours
Cooking 15 min.
When should you start or finish this recipe?
If you start now, at , you will finish around : ?.Change start time
To finish around 7pm, you'll need to have started before: .Change end time

Step by step recipe


Stage 1 - ⌛ 1 hour
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 1

Stage 2 - ⌛ 5 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 2
Squeeze 4 limes, which should give you about 125 ml of juice.

Stage 3 - ⌛ 2 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 3
Add the zest of one lime to the juice.

Preheat the oven to 180°C (360°F).

Stage 4
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 4
Put 4 egg yolks into a food-processor bowl.

Stage 5 - ⌛ 5 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 5
Beat on maximum speed for about 5 minutes until the yolks plump up a little in volume.

Stage 6 - ⌛ 3 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 6
Reduce the beater speed slightly and slowly pour in 400 g sweetened condensed milk.

Stage 7 - ⌛ 3 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 7
Reduce the beater speed further and slowly pour in the lime juice and zest.

Stage 8
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 8
Continue beating for a few more minutes until the mixture is fairly light.

Stage 9 - ⌛ 2 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 9
Pour this filling into the tart case.

Stage 10 - ⌛ 15 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 10
Cook for 10-15 minutes, just until the filling sets (check this by shaking the dish gently from side to side).

Stage 11 - ⌛ 2 hours
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 11
Leave to cool, then cover with stretch plastic film and refrigerate for at least 2 hours.

Stage 12 - ⌛ 15 min.
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 12
Just before serving, cover the top with rosettes of Chantilly (whipped cream).

Stage 13
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 13
Your Key lime pie is ready.

Stage 14
Key Lime Pie for Jeremy : Stage 14
You can replace if you prefer, like Jeremy, Chantilly cream by a meringue French or Italian, so in that case brown the top like in a pear and lime meringue pie.
Remarks
This recipe is very well known in the USA and is typical of the South. There are many different variations: with meringue topping instead of cream, crushed biscuits and butter instead of pastry, etc.

You can find mediocre versions all over Florida. These are ususally over-sweet, artificially flavoured and green coloured. Now, a good Key lime pie is not green!
Keeping: A few hours in the fridge, protected with plastic film.
Source: Based on a recipe by Stephanie Jaworski.
Support the site ❤️
This site has been around for years, with no advertising, no pop-ups, no traps, no information gathering, and I maintain it alone, out of passion.
If you liked this recipe, your support helps me to keep going.
Support cuisine-facile.com
Nutritional information
Proteins CarbohydratesFats CaloriesEnergy
Per 100 g18 g RDI=28 %97 g RDI=37 %71 g RDI=97 %1,100 kcal RDI=55 %4,608 kJ RDI=55 %
Whole recipe246 g RDI=379 %1,333 g RDI=503 %973 g RDI=1,333 %15,078 kcal RDI=754 %63,129 kJ RDI=754 %
Whole recipe
The % figures are calculated in relation to the Recommended Dietary Intake , or RDI of 2,000 k-calories (or 8,400 k-joules) per day for a woman
Possible allergens in this recipe: Gluten, milk, egg, Nuts
How much will it cost?
For 1 pie
5.85 €
Change currency:
Note: Be careful, these prices are only an estimate, you can consult the table of prices by ingredients used for this estimate.
Other recipes you may also like
News list of cooking-ez.com

Sign up to receive the latest recipes, next batch due to be sent on 2026-05-03

I am not a leaving thing
We'll never share your e-mail address with anyone else.
Post a comment or question
Posted by
I am not a leaving thing
The 1 comment already posted on this recipe
  • Thank you, I will try this recipe soon. I always try your recipes.
    Manal
    Posted by Manal september 30th 2012 at 12:32 n° 1

Follow this recipe

Receive an e-mail as soon as this recipe is modified or receives a new comment.

I am not a leaving thing
We'll never share your e-mail address with anyone else.
Alternatively: you can subscribe to the mailing list of cooling-ez.com , you will receive a e-mail for each new recipe published on the site.

Back to top of page